The final stupid weekend of what was an extremely stupid NFL regular season. I mean, they're all pretty stupid, but this one certainly felt more stupid than usual. Bad calls, bad coaching, bad penalties. Just stupidity all around. Let's summarize for Week 17...
The second stupidest officiating moment, Bill Leavy edition
With playoff implications in play, Leavy's crew had a rough go in the late moments of the Chiefs-Chargers game. The first example wasn't necessarily a bad call, but it was still poor officiating because Leavy's crew didn't perform their due diligence.
Deep in their own territory, the Chargers snapped it to Eric Weddle on a fake punt on 4th-and-2. Weddle apparently gained the first down before he fumbled, leading to a Kansas City touchdown. It was ruled by Leavy's crew, though, that his forward progress was stopped before he coughed it up. Again, might have been the right call on a bang-bang play, but why wasn't first-down yardage reviewed? And why was no explanation given? This was a play that had major implications and merited an extra look, but Leavy and Co. ignored all of the options put in place for them to get these calls right.
The stupidest officiating moment, Bill Leavy edition
But that game might not have even gone to overtime had Leavy's crew noticed that the Chargers had an illegal formation with seven men on one side of the ball when Ryan Succop missed what would have been the game-winning field goal late in the fourth quarter.
The worst part of this: Two officials—who appear from the tape to be side judge Keith Parham and umpire Ruben Fowler—were staring straight at the line from behind the Chargers rushers before the snap of the ball. They had to see the seven Chargers on the line to the right of the ball, which is illegal. Teams can have only six men on either side of the ball when it is snapped on a field-goal try.
Had a flag been thrown, Succop would have had another chance from only 36 yards out. In his career, he's an 85-percent kicker from that range. Had the kick been made, Pittsburgh would be the No. 6 seed in the AFC, rather than San Diego.
The stupidest officiating moment, Gene Steratore edition
Steratore doesn't get mentioned here very often because he's a damn good referee. But Sunday night, he overlooked something that could have cost the Cowboys their season. The play clock operator mistakenly gave Dallas only 25 seconds, rather than 40, after a 34-yard completion to Jason Witten in the fourth quarter. It was obvious the Cowboys didn't have enough time, but Steratore blew the play dead when the clock hit zeros and gave them a five-yard delay-of-game penalty anyway.
NBC's Cris Collinsworth and Al Michaels noticed immediately that something wasn't right, but nobody on Steratore's crew did. And the Cowboys never protested. Shockingly stupid.
This actually happens quite frequently, but the officials almost always pick up on the miscue from the clock operator and pick up the flag. Not this time, and in a huge moment.
Now, Dallas scored on the drive anyway and lost regardless, but this was a massive blunder that would have been criticized in a big way had it affected the outcome.
The stupidest lapse in coverage, Bengals edition
Someone tell the Ravens that A.J. Green is one of the five best receivers in football.
The stupidest lapse in coverage, Bears edition
It's 4th-and-8 with your season on the line, and you let this happen?
The stupidest example of a lack of awareness
How often do we see packs of players, or at least individuals, go ape$%#& in attempts to recovery fumbles that clearly weren't fumbles? The one damn time we get a fumble that is actually a fumble on a strange play, and nobody on either Chicago or Green Bay even makes an effort...
That might have been the difference in what was the de facto NFC North championship game.
The stupidest front-office decision
Do Jimmy Haslem, Joe Banner, Michael Lombardi and everyone else running the Cleveland Browns really believe the team they put on the field in 2013 was any better than its 4-12 record? Did they expect more from a team that traded its 2012 No. 3 overall pick midseason, lacked a half-decent starting quarterback and was still rebuilding on both sides of the ball?
I don't understand how an organization gives up on a head coach 352 days into his tenure, but the Browns did exactly that on Sunday night, firing Rob Chudzinski after a 4-12 season. That makes little sense to me, or anyone in the football world not named Haslem, Banner or Lombardi.
In Lombardi's defense, he was named general manager after Chudzinski was hired last January. But really, that ass-backwards approach probably helped lead to this and only helps establish how stupid this entire organization is.
SD - KC game:
The stars n planets were aligned in such a way to make a CBF - (coordinated brain-fart).
SD's brain-fart made KC have one too? ;) -and the refs?
-They all had Mexican...being that close to the border! ;)
-Ah so - of said cheewa-beaner!
I have a friend that signed with Cleveland as a fee agent. he made it until the last cut. Then they released him and kept another lineman. Why because the other linemen could play two positions. He looked t the assistant coach and told him he played center and guard. Cleveland coaching staff didn't even know he could play two positions. He is now with New England and very happy. The coaching staff doesn't even know what they have on the roster. No wonder the are last in the league in payer development and drafting.
Stop complaining here the the exact rule Article 3:
Defensive Team Formation
(a) When Team A presents a punt, field-goal, or Try Kick formation, a Team B player, who is within one yard of the line of scrimmage, must have his entire body outside the snapper’s shoulder pads at the snap.
(b) When Team A presents a field-goal or Try Kick formation:
(1) No more than six Team B players may be on the line of scrimmage on either side of the snapper at the snap If any one with common sense looks at the photo the end is not on the line of scrimmage.so it is a legal formation.
The Chiefs/ Chargers game was ridiculous !!!!!! I am a Steelers fan and can't believe we are not in the playoffs!!!! Obviously we should have taken care of business prior to this game but to miss a call with 7 players on 1 side with 2 officials right there is terrible!!!!!
@ChargerSBbound Not sure what you're looking at, all seven are on the line of scrimmage with an eighth player off the line of scrimmage.
@touellette The only crime I see is the overuse of exclamation points.
the reason you are not in the playoffs is because of Mike Tomlin. For example, Tomlin deliberately tried to trip Ravens receiver Jacoby Jones while returning a kick. It was all over the giant video screens.
@ChargerSBboundNo. The seventh guy you think is on the line is set back about half a yard
I can't even justify that comment with an answer. No contact was made and a faster player was right on his butt. Enough of the drama.
You had your chance to get into the playoffs and you blew it.
Ravensfan410 - Say what you want, but the fact is you need a QB. He got his payday and now he looks like he would have trouble playing Pop Warner. Not even close to being an elite QB.
And as far as the Chargers go, this is not the first time Leavy has been the center of attention as far as blown calls go. At least three blown calls against KC and every call that could determine the outcome of a game should be reviewable. Its obvious to everyone except ChargerSBbound that the Chiefs were the better team. NFL officiating needs to be better and Refs need to start being fined for blown calls. They don't hesitate o fine the players days after the game even when there was no flag thrown during the game that their fine is for.
@redav @ChargerSBbound Rhetorical Question (I don't give a $hit about your response) - Why is it that fans of a given team are the only ones so myopic that they are unable to see any transgression that goes uncalled. Holding/ Offsides/ Pass Interferenc/ To many men on the line of scrimmage. 99% of the viewing audience saw it but not the fan. To go so far as to defend it with phantom interpretations is pathetic. It just proves your lack of credibility in any debate as you are either a liar or totally oblivious. Just be glad about the low quality of NFL referees and bless your teams luck this one time. The teams that you so doggedly support would laugh at your blind allegiance and make you buy another jersey for them doing it.
@redav @ChargerSBbound Go read the rest of your rule book numb nuts. If a players helmet is even with the waist of the defensive tackle, they are on the line of scrimmage. A more visual example would be the relation of the offensive tackle to the center in passing situations. The fact that you are a Chargers fan is punishment enough so I will forgive your obvious incompetence in this matter. Loser.